Employee Benefits Benchmarking: How to Know If Your Package Is Competitive

Here is a question most employers cannot answer: how does your benefits package compare to other companies your size, in your industry, in your region?

If you do not know, you are not alone. Most employers design their benefits based on what they offered last year, what their broker suggests, and what they think they can afford. Very few take the time to benchmark their program against the market.

That is a problem, because without benchmarking, you do not know whether you are overspending on benefits that do not differentiate you, underspending in areas that are costing you talent, offering the right mix for your workforce, or getting competitive pricing from your carriers.

Benchmarking gives you the data to answer these questions. And in a labor market where benefits account for up to 30 percent of total compensation, the answers matter.

What Is Benefits Benchmarking

Benefits benchmarking is the process of comparing your benefits program — plan designs, cost sharing, employer contributions, and ancillary offerings — against what similar employers are offering.

The comparison is typically segmented by company size, industry, and geography. A 75-person manufacturing company in the Midwest should be comparing itself to other mid-size manufacturers in the region, not to Fortune 500 tech companies on the coasts.

The goal is not to copy what everyone else is doing. It is to understand where you stand so you can make intentional decisions about where to invest and where to pull back.

What to Benchmark

A comprehensive benchmarking analysis should cover several key areas.

Medical plan design is the starting point. This includes your deductible levels, coinsurance, copays, and out-of-pocket maximums compared to market averages. It also includes what types of plans you offer — PPO, HMO, HDHP — and how many options employees can choose from.

Employer contribution strategy is critical. What percentage of the premium do you cover for employee-only coverage? For dependent coverage? How does your dollar contribution compare to similarly sized companies? This is one of the areas where the gap between competitive and non-competitive employers is most visible — and most likely to influence whether a candidate accepts your offer or a current employee starts looking elsewhere.

Ancillary benefits matter more than many employers realize. Dental, vision, life insurance, short-term and long-term disability, and voluntary benefits like accident and critical illness coverage all factor into how employees perceive the value of your total package. Benchmarking can reveal whether you are over-invested in areas that employees do not value highly or missing offerings that are now considered standard.

Retirement benefits including 401(k) access, employer match formula, and vesting schedule should be compared against market norms. Competitive employer matching continues to be one of the strongest retention tools available, particularly for mid-career employees.

Non-traditional benefits are increasingly important in benchmarking exercises. Mental health support, financial wellness programs, flexible work arrangements, parental leave, and employee assistance programs are all areas where employee expectations have shifted significantly in recent years. What felt generous three years ago may now be table stakes.

How to Get Benchmarking Data

There are several ways to access benchmarking data, and the right approach depends on your size and resources.

Your benefits broker is often the best starting point. A good broker has direct market visibility across dozens or hundreds of clients and can tell you specifically how your program compares to what they are seeing in your industry and size segment. If your broker does not provide benchmarking as part of their standard service, that is worth noting — it is a baseline expectation for any broker serving employers with 25 or more employees.

Industry surveys are another valuable source. Organizations like the Kaiser Family Foundation, SHRM, Mercer, and the Bureau of Labor Statistics publish annual benefits surveys with detailed data on plan design trends, employer contributions, and benefit prevalence by industry and size.

Peer networking can also provide useful data points, though it tends to be less structured. Talking to other business leaders in your industry about their benefits approach can surface insights that surveys miss.

The key is to gather data from multiple sources and look for consistent patterns rather than anchoring on any single data point.

What Benchmarking Usually Reveals

When employers do a thorough benchmarking exercise, a few patterns come up consistently.

Health insurance employee contributions that are too high relative to the market. Employees are increasingly cost-sensitive, and plans where employees shoulder a large share of premiums stand out as a visible disadvantage in recruiting.

Mental health coverage that is inadequate or poorly communicated. Employee expectations around mental health support have shifted dramatically, and many employers have not kept pace.

Retirement plan matching that lags behind competitors. This is often one of the easiest gaps to close and one of the most impactful for retention.

Voluntary benefits that are missing or outdated. Benefits like accident insurance, critical illness coverage, legal plans, and identity theft protection are increasingly common, and their absence can make a package feel incomplete — particularly for younger employees who are comparing offers.

Over-investment in benefits that do not move the needle. Some employers spend heavily on wellness programs or perks that employees do not use or value, while underinvesting in areas like mental health, financial wellness, or parental leave that would have a measurable impact on satisfaction and retention.

How to Use Benchmarking Data

Benchmarking data is only valuable if you act on it. Here is a practical framework.

First, identify your biggest gaps. Where are you most out of step with the market? Rank the gaps by their likely impact on recruiting and retention. A health insurance contribution that is 20 points below market is a much bigger problem than a missing pet insurance option.

Second, estimate the cost to close each gap. Not every improvement requires a large investment. Adjusting your employer match formula, adding a voluntary benefit at no cost to the employer, or improving how you communicate existing benefits can all move the needle without increasing your total spend.

Third, prioritize based on your workforce. What do your employees actually value? An employee survey alongside benchmarking data gives you a much clearer picture than benchmarking alone. You may discover that your team cares more about schedule flexibility than dental coverage, or that mental health support would be more impactful than another plan option.

Fourth, set benchmarks for next year. Benchmarking is not a one-time exercise. The most effective employers review their competitive position annually and make incremental adjustments over time rather than overhauling their program every few years.

Small Employers Can Compete

One common misconception is that benchmarking is only useful for large employers. In reality, small and mid-size employers often benefit the most from benchmarking because they have the agility to make changes quickly.

A 50-person company cannot match the benefits budget of a Fortune 500 firm. But it can compete effectively by offering strong health insurance contributions, genuine flexibility, a handful of high-value voluntary benefits, and clear communication about what it offers.

Small employers often have an advantage in culture and personal attention that larger organizations cannot replicate. Benchmarking helps you identify where to invest your limited budget for maximum impact — so you are competing on strategy, not just spending.

The Bottom Line

Benefits benchmarking takes the guesswork out of your benefits strategy. It tells you where you stand, where you are falling short, and where you may be overspending. It gives you the data to make confident decisions about where to invest and how to position your company in the talent market.

The employers who win the talent competition are not necessarily the ones with the biggest budgets. They are the ones who understand what their workforce values, know where they stand relative to the market, and make intentional decisions about where to invest.

---

Want to know how your benefits package compares to the market? Schedule a free benchmarking review and we will show you exactly where you stand and where the biggest opportunities are.